Bob Bentley (director)
N/A (studio)
15 (certificate)
30 min (length)
25 November 2026 (released)
57 min
For anyone not familiar with the harrowing events of the Luxton story, which took place in September 1975 near Devon, BAFTA-winner Bob Bentley’s fascinating short RECLUSE from 1981 offers a fictionalised response to what happened.
Let’s rewind to September 23rd, 1975, when three elderly and unmarried siblings were found dead with shotgun wounds on their West Chapple Farm near Winkleigh in Devon. Siblings Frances (67), Robbie (64) and Alan Luxton (54) lead an isolated life, with the Luxton family farming the property for almost 600 years and from generation to generation. Refusing modern machinery in favour of unmodernised and traditional methods amid severe rural isolation and increasingly difficult agricultural economics, the farm gradually suffered due to financial decline. When the sibling’s father passed away in 1939, Robbie Luxton took control of the farm and insisted that old-fashioned Victorian farming methods be upheld. His refusal to modernise anything certainly didn’t help the already dire financial situation. Up until then, the three siblings remained unmarried but when Alan got engaged during the 1950s, he felt the time was right to modernise West Chapple Farm. Robbie disagreed strongly and soon, he and Alan were engaged in a nasty dispute, which even involved physical altercations. With Alan’s fiancée understandably not keen on an ancient ancient farm with next to no modern conveniences, the engagement was broken off, causing Alan, who henceforth spent many years as a recluse, to suffer from severe psychological strain. Shortly before the siblings death, tensions had escalated over potentially selling the declining farm for £80,000. The situation came to its horrific climax and upon the discovery of the bodies, the official inquest verdict concluded that the deaths were the result of a suicide pact - with Robbie shooting Francis before taking his own life and Alan also dying by suicide.
Events like these will forever inspire writers and filmmakers, in this case London-based filmmaker and artist Bob Bentley, whose 1981 half hour long drama RECLUSE is an imaginative response to the real-life event of the Luxton tragedy. Directed by Bentley and co-written with lifelong friend Paddy Fetcher (both of whom grew up in Bideford, Devon), Bentley decided to give the siblings a different family name: Huxtable. The siblings are portrayed by Maurice Denham (Charlie Huxtable), Derek Smith (Alec Huxtable) and spinster Miss Huxtable (Ann Tirard). Interestingly enough, the farm used for filming was the actual West Chapple Farm!
Released in 1981 as a supporting short, it won that year’s BAFTA for Best Short Film, received international festival screenings and was shown twice on Channel 4.
Writing in ‘What’s on in London’ and his 1981 Annual Film Review, critic F. Maurice Speed praised Recluse as “a cinematic achievement worthy of notice”, commending its atmosphere and performances.
After years in obscurity, RECLUSE was screened at The Plough Arts Centre in Torrington, Devon. Noticing that his remaining 35mm print had badly faded, Bentley donated it to the BFI National Archive for restoration. During the process, a 16mm location-rehearsal reel from 1976 — just a year after the deaths — came to light. Footage from this reel features in Oliver Balaam’s THE FOLD. Together, The Fold and Recluse offer two distinct but complementary perspectives on the Luxton family and the tragedy that continues to fascinate the local community. Both filmmakers hope their films will serve as lasting tributes to Frances, Robert and Alan. For those interested in watching RECLUSE, the short film is available on YouTube and is also included as a bonus on the BFI Flipside release of ‘The Black Panther’.
Oliver Balaam and Bob Bentley will attend a post-screening Q&A at The Plough Arts Centre, Torrington, on Wednesday 25th November at 7.30pm.