Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum (director)
Little Engine Productions (studio)
TV-14 (certificate)
109 (length)
18 November 2026 (released)
2 h
Leighton Meester plays Hannah Brooks, a strong bodyguard that is assigned to protect action film star Jack Stapleton, played by the supernatural star Jared Padalecki. Guarding Stapleton from a dangerous stalker, Jack returns to his family ranch for Christmas where the pair find themselves posing as a couple to keep his safety and anonymity from his parents who are none the wiser of the situation. It is a premise practically crafted to have misunderstandings, festive set pieces that get you in the holiday spirit and inevitable moments that make you say “awh” at any given moment.
Meester is by far the standout. She gives Hannah a practical edge and makes her feel competent and credible in her job, providing a welcome difference to the usual cheesy rom-com characters. Padalecki is charming as Jack, with the two sharing enough heartfelt and warmth in moments that keeps the central romance flickering. Yet the romance does rarely catch real fire. Their connection is more realistic and convincing in the quieter moments where they share their history and experiences, rather than moments of admitting their feelings to one another, with the script being quite clique and squeamish with its corny dialogue, leaving little for the pair to work with.
The film is best when it steps aside from the romance and delves deeper into Jack's family. Andie MacDowell brings tender love and care to her role as Jack’s mother, handing the story an emotional epicenter to guide the romance to the finish line. There are flashes of fun and silliness within, with harmless television-esque editing and character developments that keep it light hearted.
Tonally, Guarding Stars is shaky. The stalker storyline adds tension, but is repeatedly shelved by the ranch life and romantic elements. The Danger never feels urgent, and the drama doesn't provide anything memorable, in fact, the action is completely off from what the rest of the film provides, making for a whiplash of genres being included. Visually, the film is polished for the christmas vibe, but is your standard straight to streaming type of cinematography that you would expect, giving it little personality.
Director Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum delivers a serviceable cozy seasonal watch, and will be a film that can keep you entertained for a light hearted viewing experience for a relaxing night next to the fireplace.